Born and raised UWSer and Sals is the best puzza ever. Always amazing!
Possibly the best pizza on the Upper West Side. Just amazing.
I have always loved Sal & Carmine's. So happy they deliver!
So happy they're delivering more. Love this pizza shop!!
Amazing pizza. An extra sauce pie is my favorite.
Reviews from Seamless.com
I live in the west 90s in what is arguably a "pizza desert." I've always been "meh" about the pizza I order from my neighborhood places, until I found Sal & Carmine. This is my new "go-to" when I'm willing to drop a little dough on some quality stuff. This is not a cheap pie, but it's worth it. Delivery has always been fast, pizza comes hot. Very tangy, fresh, bright sauce on an incredibly robust, yeasty dough, and they aren't skimpy with toppings. Very highly recommended.
Still the reigning champ in the UWS for best pizza. We've lived here a while and have had pizza at every possible restaurant in the area. Sal and Carmine's remains the undisputed pizza champion of the UWS. Don't waste your time or money going elsewhere.
My only wish is that they'd offer other options more regularly. In particular, Sicilian and White Pies. When they do offer them, they're fantastic. But it's really hit or miss, and usually they don't offer them..
This is terrific pizza, and it looks like they sorted out their delivery issues. After I ordered I got the notification that my order would be delivered in an hour, which had me worried. But they actually showed up 30 minutes after I ordered. I was so psyched because now I know this can be my go to pizza place.
This place never disappoints, by far the best pizza for delivery on the UWS. They don't always offer delivery and shut it off at any given moment, but if they're open and delivering you have to jump on it. Seriously the best slice in the area.
Best Pizza in NY! I've been eating at Sal & Carmine's since I was in grade school. 40+ years later, it's still the best pizza I ever had. If I am in the mood for pizza, I go out of my way to get to Sal's.